Skip to content
PriceCharting uitgelegd: kloppen de prijzen van Pokémon kaarten wel?

PriceCharting explained: are Pokémon card prices actually accurate?

Ashwin Schouten|

PriceCharting is a popular tool for checking the value of Pokémon cards based on eBay sales and historical data. Although it provides a good indication of trends and prices, the values are often not the leading reference in the Netherlands. For European collectors, Cardmarket is a more important source for the current market price.

What is PriceCharting for Pokémon cards?

PriceCharting is one of the best-known websites in the world for checking the value of Pokémon cards. Many collectors use this tool to quickly get an indication of what a card is worth, both ungraded and graded (for example, PSA 10).

But how exactly does PriceCharting work? And more importantly: how reliable are these prices, especially for Dutch collectors? In this blog, we explain everything you need to know.

How does PriceCharting work?

PriceCharting is essentially a price database based on actual sales. The website continuously collects data from sold items, especially from platforms such as eBay, and uses this data to calculate an average value.

According to PriceCharting itself, prices are determined by analyzing all sales, filtering out bad data, and then calculating an average price per card and condition. 

This means that on PriceCharting you can often see:

  • The average price of a card
  • The difference between graded and ungraded cards
  • Historical price trends
  • Whether a card is increasing or decreasing in value

In addition, you can easily search by name, set, or card number, and even use photos to identify cards.

What can you find on PriceCharting?

For Pokémon collectors, PriceCharting is particularly interesting because it offers a broad overview of the market. You can find thousands of cards there, from old Base Set cards to modern sets.

The most important features are:

  • Price per card – based on recent sales
  • Grading prices – PSA, BGS, and other grades
  • Price charts – see how the value develops
  • Set overviews – complete lists with values per set

This makes PriceCharting particularly useful for:

  • Quick price checks
  • Investing in Pokémon cards
  • Tracking trends
  • Estimating the value of your collection

Why PriceCharting is popular

The reason so many collectors use PriceCharting is simple: it is fast and easy to use. Within a few seconds, you get an indication of what a card is worth, without having to analyze dozens of sales yourself.

In addition, the platform is completely free and contains data from a huge number of sales. This makes it feel like a reliable source to many users.

But how reliable are the prices?

Although PriceCharting is a good tool, it is important to understand that the prices do not always reflect the actual market price exactly.

The biggest reason for this is that PriceCharting is primarily based on eBay sales. 

This leads to several important limitations:

  • Not all sales are included
  • International prices may differ from European prices
  • Shipping costs and location play a role
  • Price differences per language (EN vs. EU cards)

In addition, prices can be influenced by hype, auctions, or exceptional sales. After all, the value of a Pokémon card is determined by multiple factors such as condition, rarity, and demand. 

Why PriceCharting is less authoritative in the Netherlands

For Dutch and European collectors, it is important to know that PriceCharting is not the most authoritative price source.

The European market works differently from the American market. In Europe, the value of Pokémon cards is primarily determined by supply and demand on European platforms.

Therefore, prices on PriceCharting can:

  • Be too high (due to American hype)
  • Be too low (due to a lack of EU data)
  • Not match what cards actually sell for here

Many sources therefore also indicate that PriceCharting should primarily be used as a guideline and not as an exact price. 

Why Cardmarket is more important in Europe

In the Netherlands and the rest of Europe, Cardmarket is the most important marketplace for Pokémon cards. Thousands of cards are traded here daily by European sellers and buyers.

This means that Cardmarket:

  • Shows the actual European market price
  • Takes language and condition into account
  • Shows immediately what cards currently cost

Many guides therefore advise using both PriceCharting and Cardmarket to get a good idea of the value.

Want to know exactly how Cardmarket works and how to interpret prices there? Then check out this comprehensive guide: Cardmarket guide – how does Cardmarket work?

How to use PriceCharting correctly?

The best way to use PriceCharting is as a supplementary tool, not as the only source.

A good approach is:

  1. Check the card on PriceCharting (trend and global price)
  2. Check the card on Cardmarket (current EU price)
  3. Compare multiple listings and conditions

This way, you get a much more realistic idea of what a card is actually worth.

Conclusion

PriceCharting is a convenient and popular tool for quickly checking the value of Pokémon cards. The platform provides insight into trends, historical prices, and global market values.

But for Dutch collectors, it is important to realize that these prices are not always authoritative. The actual market price is often closer to what you see on European platforms such as Cardmarket.

Therefore, use PriceCharting as a tool, but always base your buying or selling decisions on the current European market.

Back to blog